Install Sam free

★ 4.9 (107 reviews) Built for Shopify Free plan available

Playbooks

Stopping High-Risk Orders at Checkout Before They Turn into Claims

TL;DR

To stop high risk orders and shipping claims from draining your protection fund, screen orders before fulfillment. Use Shopify Flow to hold orders flagged by Shopify risk analysis, use Sam Shipping Protection customer tag exclusions to hide the widget from signed-in repeat claim abusers, and use server-side checkout validation to block flagged emails or addresses.

Managing high risk orders and shipping claims as two connected parts of your fulfillment pipeline keeps a few bad orders from draining the protection fees you collect from honest buyers. When you run a self-funded order protection program with Sam Shipping Protection, you keep 100% of the protection fees and decide every claim yourself—so every bad shipment you stop before it leaves the warehouse protects both your inventory and your protection fund.

Many Shopify stores treat checkout fraud screening and post-delivery shipping claims as separate tasks. In practice, they overlap: a buyer who exploits policies for free replacements or uses a compromised card often selects the shipping protection add-on at checkout hoping it will trigger a fast, low-scrutiny refund or reshipment later.

This guide explains checkout fraud filter vs claim fraud, how to hold high-risk protected orders in Shopify Flow before your 3PL ships them, how to hide the protection widget from tagged accounts, and how to block repeat claim abusers at checkout.

Why do high-risk orders turn into shipping protection claims?

When an honest customer pays a protection fee at cart or checkout, they want peace of mind in case a carrier loses or damages their parcel. Bad actors look at the same widget for a different reason: they treat order protection as a faster path to a cash refund or a second free shipment.

High-risk orders usually reach your claims queue in one of two ways if you do not filter them upstream:

  • Policy and reship abuse (“double dipping”): A buyer places a valid payment for a high-ticket item, adds shipping protection for a few dollars, receives the parcel, and immediately files a “delivered but not received” or damaged-box claim to get a free replacement order (-R order) or a refund while keeping the goods.
  • Priority-fulfillment bypass on risky payments: Many stores tag protected orders (for example, shipping-protection) so their warehouse prioritizes packing them. If your fulfillment automation ships tagged orders immediately without checking Shopify’s risk assessment first, an order with elevated payment risk can leave the warehouse before anyone reviews it.

Catching those orders after delivery is expensive. By the time a suspicious claim arrives, you have already paid for the product cost, outbound shipping, and pick-and-pack labor.

How does a checkout fraud filter compare to claim fraud review?

Understanding checkout fraud filter vs claim fraud comes down to when each check runs and which signals are available. A checkout filter inspects the buyer’s identity, cart, and address before an order is created or shipped, while claim review inspects delivery evidence after the carrier handles the parcel.

StageWhat you are screening forSignals to checkAction to take
1. Pre-checkout & checkout validationRepeat claim abusers, disposable emails, reshipping mules, or flagged addressesCustomer tags (claim-abuse), email domain, shipping street address, phone numberHide the protection widget from tagged accounts; block known abusive emails or addresses at checkout
2. Pre-fulfillment order risk reviewCompromised payment methods, mismatched billing/shipping locations, proxy IPsShopify OrderRiskAssessment (riskLevel and facts), order value, first-time buyer statusHold the fulfillment order via fulfillmentOrderHold in Shopify Flow before the warehouse ships
3. Post-delivery claim reviewOpportunistic false claims, altered photos, or claims contradicting carrier scansCarrier tracking, delivery photos, buyer’s uploaded photos, past claims from the same customer or addressResolve with store credit or a replacement instead of cash, or cancel the claim in Sam under your policy

You need all three layers. A checkout filter cannot stop a parcel from being stolen off a porch, and a post-delivery claims portal cannot recover inventory shipped to a stolen-card drop address.

How do you hold high-risk protected orders before fulfillment with Shopify Flow?

When you enable automatic order tagging in Sam Shipping Protection (included on the Standard $9/month and Plus $29/month plans; see plans and the Starter order limit), Sam appends your chosen tag—such as shipping-protection—to every protected order. You configure this under Protection > Rules > Order fulfillment, tags & product by ticking Tag orders with a protection item (see the auto-fulfill and order tags guide and our walkthrough on using order tags for shipping protection).

To ensure a high-risk order with shipping protection is never auto-shipped by your warehouse or 3PL before review, build a workflow in Shopify Flow that pauses fulfillment whenever Shopify’s fraud analysis flags the order:

  1. Open Shopify Flow in your Shopify admin and click Create workflow.
  2. Select the Order risk analyzed trigger. Shopify runs this trigger as soon as it generates the order’s OrderRiskAssessment.
  3. Add a Condition checking if the order Risk level is High or Medium (or if the recommendation is to investigate or cancel).
  4. Optional: Add a second condition checking if Order / tags includes shipping-protection (or if any line item has product type sam_protect_shipping) for a dedicated alert on protected orders.
  5. Add the Hold fulfillment order action, which uses Shopify’s fulfillmentOrderHold mutation to stop your warehouse, ShipStation, or 3PL from picking the order.
  6. Add an Internal email or Slack notification action so your team can verify the buyer before releasing the hold or cancelling the order.

Which Sam auto-fulfillment timing works best for high-risk review?

In Protection > Rules > Order fulfillment, tags & product, Sam offers three Auto fulfillment options for the digital sam_protect_shipping item:

  • Mark as fulfilled when the first item is fulfilled
  • Mark as fulfilled when all other items are fulfilled
  • Mark as fulfilled immediately after purchase

If you hold high-risk orders for review before shipping, select one of the first two options rather than immediately after purchase. That way, when Shopify Flow places a fulfillment hold on a risky order, the protection line item stays unfulfilled alongside the physical items until your team approves or cancels the order.

How do you hide the shipping protection widget from repeat claim abusers?

Some problem buyers are signed-in account holders who have filed several questionable “missing package” or “damaged box” claims in a row. You may still allow them to buy from your store—for example, with signature-required delivery—without letting them opt into your protection program again.

On the Standard ($9/month) and Plus ($29/month) plans, Sam Shipping Protection hides the protection widget from specific shoppers using Shopify customer tags under Protection > Rules > Targeting & exclusions (see hide the widget from some customers or carts):

  1. In Shopify admin under Customers, open the customer profile and add a tag such as no-protection or claim-abuse.
  2. In Sam Shipping Protection, click Protection and open Targeting & exclusions under Rules.
  3. Under Who sees the widget, set Hide from to Customers with certain tags.
  4. Enter no-protection (or claim-abuse), click Add tag, and click Save.

What happens when a tagged customer tries to add protection?

  • Cart and cart drawer: When a signed-in customer with your excluded tag views the cart, Sam hides the widget and removes any sam_protect_shipping item already in the cart.
  • Shopify Plus checkout: On the Plus plan, the checkout extension follows Hide from and removes protection for excluded signed-in customers.
  • Minimum cart total and country rules (Plus): Under the same card, Plus merchants can tick Only show when the cart total reaches a minimum and Only show in certain countries to hide the cart widget on order bands or destinations with high claim rates.

How do you block repeat claim abusers who check out as guests?

Hiding the Sam widget by customer tag works when the buyer logs into their account. However, serial claim abusers often try to bypass account restrictions by checking out as a guest, creating a new email or +alias, or entering the same delivery address under a slightly different name.

Because storefront scripts run in the browser and Shopify only attaches customer tags to signed-in sessions, customer tag exclusions cannot stop a guest checkout using a new email.

To block repeat claim abusers before they place another order, use Shopify’s Cart and Checkout Validation Function API. Unlike storefront scripts that run in the browser, a Checkout Validation Function runs server-side on Shopify’s infrastructure during checkout progression and cannot be bypassed.

With a Shopify checkout fraud prevention app such as LabX Fraud Filter, you can enforce server-side checkout rules before payment is captured:

  • Block specific emails and disposable domains: Stop known abusive buyers or throwaway email services at checkout.
  • Block flagged shipping addresses or ZIP codes: Block checkout whenever a street address or reshipper suite with repeated false claims is entered, even under a new guest email.
  • Activate Sam’s built-in checkout rules: In Settings > Checkout > Checkout rules, set Shipping protection: block on local pickup and Shipping protection: require another product to Active so shoppers cannot buy protection on pickup orders or check out with only the protection item.

How should you review and resolve suspicious claims in Sam Shipping Protection?

Even with checkout validation and Shopify Flow holds in place, an occasional questionable claim will reach your post-delivery queue. Because Sam is a self-funded platform rather than a third-party provider, you inspect the evidence and choose the outcome that protects your margins.

Here is how to handle a suspicious claim step by step inside Sam’s claim flow:

  1. Let the claim portal enforce your first gate: Sam’s storefront claim portal (/apps/protect/claims) requires the customer to look up their order by matching email and order number, select the item, state a reason, and upload at least one photo (up to 10 images of 5 MB each). It only accepts fulfilled orders and allows one claim per order, blocking duplicate claims on the same purchase.
  2. Inspect the buyer’s report and timeline: In Sam, open Claims and click the claim (moving its status from Requested to In progress). Check the Claimable total under Claimed items—which excludes the protection fee—and compare the Buyer’s report and uploaded photos against carrier tracking and delivery scans (see our guide to fraudulent shipping protection claims).
  3. Choose the safest resolution for grey-area claims: If a first-time claim looks plausible but comes from a higher-risk order, click Resolve claim and consider issuing Store credit or a Reorder rather than a cash Refund (see store credit vs refund vs reship for claims and the resolve a claim guide). When you choose Reorder, Sam creates an uncharged -R replacement order (such as #1001-R); always open the -R order in Shopify admin to check its full street address and ZIP code before fulfilling it.
  4. Cancel claims that violate your published policy: If the evidence contradicts carrier proof of delivery or falls outside your published terms (see how to write a lost and stolen package policy), click More actions > Cancel claim, enter the Reason for cancelling, and confirm. Sam marks the claim Cancelled without paying out, and each claim is settled once. Keep your written explanation and carrier evidence on file in case the buyer opens a dispute with their bank (see reducing chargebacks for lost and stolen orders).
  5. Tag the customer profile immediately: Whenever you cancel an abusive claim or spot a repeat pattern, add your no-protection or claim-abuse customer tag in Shopify admin right away—and add their address or email to your checkout blocklist if needed—so their next order is caught before another claim can be filed.

Frequently asked questions

Does shipping protection cover high-risk orders placed with stolen credit cards?

No. Shipping protection covers physical delivery issues—packages lost in transit, damaged on the way, or stolen after delivery—for legitimate orders. It does not cover payment fraud or unauthorized-card chargebacks. Orders flagged as high risk by Shopify should be held and verified or cancelled before fulfillment.

How can I hide the shipping protection widget from repeat claim abusers?

In Sam Shipping Protection (on the Standard $9/month and Plus $29/month plans), open Protection, go to Rules > Targeting & exclusions, set Hide from to Customers with certain tags, add a tag such as no-protection or claim-abuse, and click Save. Signed-in customers with that tag will not see the widget in the cart or Shopify Plus checkout, and any protection item in their cart is removed automatically.

What if a repeat claim abuser checks out as a guest to bypass customer tag exclusions?

Because Shopify only identifies customer tags when a shopper is signed into their account, a repeat abuser who checks out as a guest or creates a new email will still see storefront widgets. To block repeat abusers at checkout regardless of login state, use a Shopify Cart and Checkout Validation Function app to block known abusive email addresses, disposable domains, or flagged shipping addresses server-side.

Can a customer file multiple shipping protection claims on the same Shopify order?

No. In Sam Shipping Protection, the claim portal only accepts fulfilled orders, allows one claim per order, and settles each claim once. You review the buyer’s report and photos on the Claims page and choose whether to issue a refund, store credit, or a replacement order—or cancel the claim if it falls outside your policy.

Sources

  1. Shopify.dev: OrderRiskAssessment GraphQL object
  2. Shopify.dev: fulfillmentOrderHold GraphQL mutation
  3. Shopify.dev: Cart and Checkout Validation Function API
  4. Shopify.dev: About Shopify Flow

Part of our guide: Order protection →

Keep 100% of your protection fees

Sam Shipping Protection is free for your first 50 orders a month.

Install free on Shopify

★ 4.9 (107 reviews) Built for Shopify Free plan available