Install Sam free

★ 4.9 (107 reviews) Built for Shopify Free plan available

Guides

Types of Social Proof in Ecommerce, With Examples

TL;DR

Social proof is the pull we feel to follow what other people do. In ecommerce it comes in five classic types: customer (reviews, photos), wisdom of the crowd (sales, visitors, sold counts), wisdom of friends (referrals), expert (press, specialists) and celebrity or influencer. Pick the types your real data supports, start with customer reviews, and disclose any paid or gifted endorsement.

There are five classic types of social proof: customer (or user), wisdom of the crowd, wisdom of friends, expert and celebrity. Online stores use all five, plus a sixth flavor that only the web makes easy: live store activity, such as recent sales and visitor counts.

Each type answers a slightly different doubt, needs different data and comes with its own rules. This post walks through each one with ecommerce examples, then shows which types fit your store today. For the full setup and placement guide, see our social proof guide for Shopify.

What is social proof?

Social proof is the pull we feel to follow what other people do, especially when we are unsure. Psychologist Robert Cialdini lists it as one of his principles of persuasion, next to reciprocity, scarcity and authority (Influence at Work).

Investor Aileen Lee put it simply in a 2011 essay: social proof is “the positive influence created when someone finds out that others are doing something” (TechCrunch). Her example was a line outside a club. The line itself tells you the place is worth the wait.

Online, the line is invisible. A first-time visitor can’t see other shoppers, touch the product or meet you. So your store has to show the evidence on the page:

  • Who else bought or recommends this
  • How many people did
  • Whether it worked out for them

What are the main types of social proof?

Lee’s essay grouped social proof into five types (TechCrunch). Here they are, translated into what a Shopify store can actually show.

TypeThe shopper’s doubt it answersEcommerce examplesData you need
Customer (user)“Did it work for people like me?”Product reviews, star ratings, customer photos, testimonialsReal buyers who agree to share
Wisdom of the crowd“Is this popular, is this store real?”Recent sales pop-ups, sold counts, live visitors, a “customers served” totalYour orders, sessions and totals
Wisdom of friends“Would someone I know buy here?”Referral links, “share with a friend” offers, gift purchasesA referral or sharing setup
Expert“Does someone who knows the field approve?”Press mentions, dermatologist or trainer reviews, lab testsA real review or mention
Celebrity and influencer“Does someone I follow use this?”Creator posts, sponsored reviews, ambassador collectionsA real relationship, disclosed

Low stock alerts and countdown timers often get lumped in with social proof. They are really scarcity and urgency, a separate principle in Cialdini’s list. We cover them in scarcity marketing with low stock alerts.

What does customer social proof look like?

Customer social proof is evidence from people who already bought. It is the most useful type for most stores because it is about the exact product on the page, after it arrived.

Ecommerce examples:

  • Star ratings and review counts under the product title and on collection cards
  • Written reviews that mention size, fit, taste or durability
  • Customer photos and videos, such as unboxing clips or “how I wear it” shots
  • Testimonials on the home page or a landing page, with a first name and city
  • Review pop-ups that surface a recent 5-star review while the shopper browses

How to build it: send a review request after delivery, make leaving a photo easy, and reply to the critical reviews as well as the glowing ones. If you give a discount for a review, say so next to that review.

The rules are strict here. The FTC’s rule on consumer reviews bans writing or buying reviews that misrepresent whether the reviewer exists or used the product. It also bans showing only the good reviews while implying they are all the reviews you got (16 CFR Part 465). Our post on fake social proof and FTC rules goes into detail.

What is wisdom of the crowd social proof?

Wisdom of the crowd shows that many people chose you. Lee’s classic example is the “Over 1 Million Served” sign McDonald’s started using in 1955 (TechCrunch). The message is “a lot of people can’t be wrong.”

In ecommerce this splits into two groups:

Totals. For example, “Over 10,000 orders shipped,” a follower count, or a review count on your home page. These change slowly and suit the home page and about page.

Live activity. Signals that show what is happening in the store right now:

  • A recent sales pop-up: “Emma in London bought Linen Shirt, 2 minutes ago”
  • A sold count: “26 orders in the last 24 hours”
  • A live visitor count: “18 people are viewing this right now”
  • Cart activity: “Someone added Travel Bag to their cart”

Live activity is what most social proof apps add, because it needs a live feed of orders and sessions. It only works when the numbers are real and big enough to mean something. On a quiet store, a visitor counter showing “1” hurts more than it helps; see live visitor counters and sold count badges for when each one starts to make sense.

Totals have a trap too. The same FTC rule bans buying fake followers, views or other “indicators of social media influence” that you know are fake to make a business look bigger (16 CFR 465.8).

What is wisdom of friends social proof?

Wisdom of friends is a recommendation from someone the shopper already knows. Lee called it the likely “killer app” of social proof for its one-to-one impact (TechCrunch). A friend’s “I love this” usually beats a stranger’s five stars.

You can’t put a friend’s voice on your product page. But you can make it easy for happy customers to pass the word on:

  • Referral offers: “Give $10, get $10” links that customers send to friends
  • Share prompts on the thank-you page or in the shipping email
  • Gift options, so a buyer can send the product to someone else
  • Group or family offers where buying together makes sense, for example matching sets

This type is slow to start, since it depends on customers you already have. It pays off later, when each happy buyer brings in someone who already trusts them.

What is expert social proof?

Expert social proof is approval from someone with real knowledge of the field. Shoppers borrow that person’s judgment instead of researching on their own.

Ecommerce examples:

  • Press mentions: “As featured in” logos, linked to the actual article
  • Specialist reviews: a dermatologist on a skincare line, a coach on running shoes, a chef on cookware
  • Independent tests and certifications, such as a lab report or an organic certificate
  • Awards from a real competition or trade body

The FTC Endorsement Guides set a clear bar. If you present someone as an expert, their qualifications must actually give them that expertise. Their endorsement must also be based on a real evaluation of the product (16 CFR 255.3). A press logo should link to a real article, not a paid listing dressed up as coverage.

What is celebrity and influencer social proof?

Celebrity social proof is an endorsement from someone the shopper admires or follows. For most Shopify stores, that means creators and niche influencers rather than film stars.

Ecommerce examples:

  • Creator posts showing the product in daily use
  • Ambassador or collab collections named after a creator
  • Reposted creator content on product pages, with permission

The key rule is disclosure. Under the Endorsement Guides, a connection between you and the endorser that the audience would not expect must be disclosed clearly and conspicuously. That includes payment, and also free or discounted products, even when you didn’t require a post in return (16 CFR 255.5). Endorsements must also reflect the endorser’s honest opinion, and you can’t reword them to change what they meant (16 CFR 255.1).

Which types of social proof fit your store right now?

Pick the types your real data can support today. Showing a weak version of a type, like a visitor counter stuck at 1, does more harm than leaving it off.

Your storeStart withAdd later
New, few ordersReviews from first buyers, honest testimonials, a press mention if you have oneRecent sales once orders come in
Steady ordersReviews, recent sales pop-ups, review pop-upsSold counts on best sellers, referral offers
High trafficAll of the above, plus live visitors and cart activity on busy pagesExpert or creator partnerships, disclosed

If you’re just starting, our post on social proof for new stores covers how to stretch a small number of real orders honestly.

How do you add these types of social proof on Shopify?

Static types, such as testimonials, press logos and certifications, can usually go in your theme’s text or logo sections. Reviews need a reviews app. Live crowd signals need an app that reads your orders and sessions.

Sam FOMO covers the customer and crowd types with pop-ups built from your store data:

TypeSam FOMO notificationData source
CustomerProduct ReviewsRecent 5-star reviews or ratings from Judge.me or Shopify product ratings
Wisdom of the crowdRecent SalesYour paid Shopify orders, or a CSV of real orders from another channel
Wisdom of the crowdSold CountOrders for a product in a time window you choose
Wisdom of the crowdLive Visitors, Recent VisitorsReal sessions on the page or store
Wisdom of the crowdCart Notification, Cart SummaryReal add-to-cart activity

To set one up, open Notifications, click Create notification, pick the type and click Add (create a notification). For Recent Sales, you can hide test orders and exclude orders by tag, such as wholesale (Recent Sales guide). The other types are explained in the urgency and cart guide.

Wisdom of friends, expert and influencer proof come from outside the app: referral tools, PR and creator partnerships.

What mistakes should you avoid with each type?

A quick checklist, by type:

  • Customer: don’t write reviews yourself, don’t hide the critical ones, and disclose incentives.
  • Crowd: don’t invent orders or visitors, and don’t buy followers. If a number is small, show a longer time window or skip it.
  • Friends: don’t post fake “my friend recommended” messages. Let real customers do the sharing.
  • Expert: only call someone an expert if they are one, and only show press logos for real coverage.
  • Influencer: disclose payment and free products, and don’t edit a creator’s words to say more than they did.

Every type of social proof works for the same reason: shoppers believe it comes from real people. Keep it that way, and each signal you add makes the next one more believable. Wondering whether sales pop-ups count as honest? Read are recent sales popups fake?

Frequently asked questions

What is social proof in simple terms?

Social proof is the tendency to look at what other people do when we are not sure what to do ourselves. In a store, it means showing shoppers that real people bought, used and liked a product, through reviews, recent sales, recommendations or endorsements.

What are the main types of social proof?

A common framework, from a 2011 TechCrunch essay by investor Aileen Lee, lists five: expert, celebrity, user, wisdom of the crowds and wisdom of your friends. Online stores also lean on real-time activity, such as recent sales and live visitors, which fits under wisdom of the crowd.

Which type of social proof should a Shopify store start with?

Customer social proof, mainly product reviews from real buyers. It speaks to the exact product the shopper is looking at, and you can start collecting it after your first orders. Add activity signals such as recent sales once you have steady orders.

Do I have to disclose gifted products in influencer posts?

In the US, yes, when the connection is not obvious to the audience. The FTC Endorsement Guides list free or discounted products as a material connection that must be disclosed clearly and conspicuously. This is general information, not legal advice.

Sources

  1. TechCrunch: Social Proof Is The New Marketing (Aileen Lee, Nov 27, 2011)
  2. Influence at Work: Principles of persuasion (Robert Cialdini)
  3. eCFR: 16 CFR Part 255, Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising
  4. eCFR: 16 CFR Part 465, Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials

Part of our guide: Social proof →

Turn store activity into social proof

Install Sam FOMO free and turn on your first sales pop-up in minutes.

Install free on Shopify

★ 4.6 (17 reviews) Built for Shopify Free plan available