Subscription boxes ship every cycle, so a customer who stays for a year receives twelve parcels or more, and each one can be lost, damaged or stolen. One bad delivery handled poorly can end a subscription that was worth far more than the box. Shipping protection helps, but subscriptions raise questions that one-off orders do not.
For the basics, see the shipping protection guide.
Does protection cover renewals?
That depends on two apps working together:
- Your subscription app creates renewal orders automatically.
- Your protection app adds the fee when a customer checks out.
Renewal orders often skip the cart and checkout, so a cart widget never sees them. Check with both apps whether renewals can carry the protection fee. If not, treat protection as covering the first order only, and say so in your policy.
What are your options?
| Option | How it works | Trade-off |
|---|---|---|
| Protect the first order only | Customer adds protection at sign-up checkout | Simple; renewals are covered by your own policy |
| Recurring protection fee | Fee added to each renewal, if both apps support it | Funded cover every cycle; needs compatibility |
| Build cover into the price | No separate fee; you fund replacements | Simplest for customers; claims come from margin |
How should you handle a missing box?
- Reply fast: subscribers expect the next box soon, so delays feel worse.
- Replace or credit: send a replacement if stock allows, or credit the next box.
- Keep it simple: a one-click claim from the order email or account page.
- Watch for patterns: repeated losses at one address may need a pickup point or signature.
See what to do when a package is lost and delivered but not received claims.
How do you price protection for subscriptions?
Work from your own numbers: the share of boxes lost or damaged per cycle and the cost to replace one. Because boxes are similar each time, the math is often simpler than for a general store. See how much to charge for shipping protection.
Why does it matter for retention?
A subscriber’s value is the sum of every future box. A lost box resolved in a day keeps that value; one that takes weeks of emails may cost it. Track cancellations that follow a delivery problem to see how much this matters for your brand.
How do you test compatibility before launch?
- Place a test subscription order with protection added.
- Trigger or wait for the first renewal order in a test store.
- Check whether the renewal includes the protection line item and the right price.
- Check that the protection item is fulfilled automatically and does not block box fulfillment.
- File a test claim against the renewal order.
If renewals do not carry protection, write your policy around the first order and handle renewal losses under your own replacement rule.
What should your policy say?
- Whether protection covers the first order, every renewal, or both.
- How and when to report a missing box.
- What you offer: replacement, credit or refund.
To set up protection and claims, see Sam Shipping Protection.
Frequently asked questions
Does shipping protection apply to subscription renewals?
It depends on how your subscription app creates renewal orders and whether your protection app adds the fee to them. Many stores protect the first order only unless they confirm renewals are supported.
What should I do when a subscription box goes missing?
Replace it quickly where you can, or credit the next box. A single lost parcel should not end a subscription.
Should the protection fee be part of the subscription price?
Some brands build delivery cover into the price instead of charging a separate fee. That keeps renewals simple but means you fund claims from margin.
Part of our guide: Shipping protection →